Does X Still Penalize Links? 6.4 Million Posts Measured

Yes, but mostly for large accounts. We compared each X account's posts that carry a link with the same account's posts that do not, across 6,447,046 original posts from 285,579 accounts published between July 15 and October 7, 2026. At the median, a text post with a link drew 10% fewer views than the same account's text posts without one, and a post with an image or video drew 7% fewer when it also carried a link. The gap grows with audience size: for accounts with more than 1 million followers, text posts with a link drew 30% fewer views, while for accounts under 1,000 followers they drew 17% more.

The question matters because X answered it this summer. At the end of July 2026, Paul Graham asked whether X still penalizes posts with links and Elon Musk replied "We haven't for over a year", while Nikita Bier, then X's head of product, told Mark Zuckerberg that links no longer need to go in replies. Figures in circulation range from 30% to 50% fewer views in marketing guides to 94% fewer views in an analysis reported by PPC Land; X has not published a figure. In April 2026, Nieman Lab analyzed thousands of posts from 18 news publishers and concluded that links do seem to hurt publishers on X; that comparison looked at engagement across publishers, while ours looks at views and compares each of 285,579 accounts with itself. Our numbers come from PlayerSells' own crawler, which reads the public view, like and bookmark counters on X posts. They measure what happened to posts, not what X's ranking code intends, and every table below gives its sample size.

Key findings

• On X, original text posts with a link drew 10% fewer views than the same account's text posts without a link (median across 18,341 accounts, posts from July 15 to October 7, 2026).
• The link gap on X grows with account size: 17% more views for accounts under 1,000 followers, 8% fewer at 10,000 to 99,999 followers and 30% fewer for accounts with over 1 million followers.
• News accounts on X drew 30% fewer views on text posts with a link than on their own text posts without one (1,014 accounts).
• X text posts with a link collected 48% fewer likes per view than the same account's text posts without a link, a larger gap than the gap in views.
• X posts that kept the link out of the post and put it in the author's own reply drew 21% more views than the same account's posts with the link in the post itself (text posts, 385 accounts).
• The link gap on X did not shrink after Musk's July 2026 statement: 13% fewer before it, 10% fewer from July 29 to September 7 and 14% fewer from September 8 to October 7.

Does X penalize posts with links?

Posts with a link get fewer views on X, but far fewer only on large accounts. Across 18,341 accounts that published at least three text posts with a link and three without, the median account's link posts drew 10% fewer views, and 58.5% of those accounts saw fewer views on their link posts. With an image or video attached, the gap was 7% fewer across 41,078 accounts. That is a real gap, but a much smaller one than the 30% to 94% figures that circulate, and for 41.5% of accounts link posts did at least as well as their link-free posts.

We compare each account with itself because a plain comparison of all link posts against all other posts mixes up who posts links with what a link does. In our sample the median text post with a link came from an account with 125,055 followers, against 82,020 for a text post without one, and a cross-account comparison inherits that difference.

Original X posts published July 15 to October 7, 2026, views read at least 48 hours after posting. Median of each account's ratio (median views of its link posts divided by median views of its link-free posts of the same type). 95% bootstrap interval for the text-only median: -11.4% to -9.5%.

Why do bigger accounts lose more views on link posts?

The link gap is close to zero for small accounts and widest for the largest ones. Accounts under 1,000 followers drew 17% more views on text posts with a link, accounts with 1,000 to 9,999 followers 1% more, and the gap then widens at every step to 30% fewer for accounts with more than 1 million followers. Posts with an image or video follow the same direction with a smaller spread, from 9% more to 15% fewer.

Change in median views against the same account's posts of the same type without a link. Follower band from the median follower count recorded when the account's posts were read. Original posts, July 15 to October 7, 2026.

Our data cannot show why. One explanation that fits the numbers: a large account gets much of its reach from recommendations to people who do not follow it, and X ranks those on predicted likes, replies and reposts. A link post earns fewer of those per view (see the section on likes below), so it is recommended less. A small account's views come mostly from its own followers, where that matters less. This is a reading of the pattern, not something we measured inside X.

Do news accounts lose more views when they post links?

Yes. News accounts, many of which post links to their own articles, drew 30% fewer views on text posts with a link than on their own text posts without one, across 1,014 accounts. With an image or video the gap was 11% fewer. Among news accounts with more than 1 million followers the gap was 44% fewer (112 accounts). For publishers that rely on X for referral traffic, this is the number to plan around: the post that carries the article link reaches fewer people than the post that does not.

Categories from PlayerSells' account classifier, which assigns one topic per account from its profile and posts; accounts without a confident topic are in the last row. Only categories with at least 100 accounts in the text comparison are shown.

Do link posts on X get fewer likes?

Yes, and by more than they lose in views. Per view, text posts with a link collected 48% fewer likes than the same account's text posts without one, and 26% fewer with an image or video. Replies per view fell further, 60% fewer on text posts, while bookmarks per view on text posts barely moved (+0.3%). A reader who taps a link leaves X instead of liking the post, which is consistent with the view gap above: engagement is what X's recommendation system predicts, and link posts produce less of it.

Change against the same account's posts of the same type without a link, computed from each group's totals (for example total likes divided by total views), median across 18,254 accounts (text) and 40,986 accounts (image or video).

Does putting the link in a reply still help on X?

It did in our data, even after X said it was no longer needed. Posts that kept the link out of the post and put it in the author's own reply drew 21% more views than the same account's posts with the link in the post itself (text posts, 385 accounts), and 16% more with an image or video (4,034 accounts). Against the same account's posts with no link anywhere, link-in-reply posts were level or slightly ahead: +2.8% for text and +5.5% with an image or video.

Part of that advantage comes from the reply itself. Posts with a reply from the author that carried no link drew 13% more views than the same account's single posts (image or video, 1,708 accounts), and the link-in-reply posts drew 6% fewer views than those threaded posts. So a reply under your own post adds views, and moving the link into it avoids most of the link gap.

Accounts with at least three link-in-reply posts and at least three posts in the comparison group. A link-in-reply post is an original post without a link whose author replied to it with a post that carries one. Original posts, July 15 to October 7, 2026, views read at least 48 hours after posting.

Did anything change after Musk said X does not penalize links?

No. The text-post gap was 13% fewer in the two weeks before the exchange (July 15 to 28), 10% fewer from July 29 to September 7, and 14% fewer from September 8, when X replaced creator revenue sharing with its Original Content Rewards program, to October 7. Posts with an image or video were just as steady: -8.3%, -7.5% and -8.9%. That fits Musk's own words, which described no change in July: if no link rule was switched off then, the gap had no reason to move, and it did not.

Accounts did not change how often they post links either. Among 3,888 accounts with at least ten original posts in both the first and the last period, the median account carried a link on 9.1% of its posts from July 15 to 28 and on 8.7% from September 8 to October 7; 36.3% of those accounts raised their share and 31.5% lowered it.

Each account compared with itself inside each period, at least three posts in each group. Our post crawler expanded during the summer, so fewer accounts qualify in the first two weeks.

How we measured

PlayerSells runs its own crawler of public X profiles and posts for its account directory. For this report we took every original post it had read that was published between July 15 and October 7, 2026: 6,447,046 posts from 285,579 accounts. Reposts, quote posts, replies and thread continuations were left out, so every post is the account's own top-level post. We kept only posts whose view counter was read at least 48 hours after publication, because a post collects most of its views in its first two days, and a later reading replaces an earlier one.

A post counts as a link post when X reports at least one URL in it, usually shown as a preview card. Photos and videos uploaded to X are not links. We split posts into text only and posts with an image or video, because attached media changes reach and link posts are more often text only: 42% of link posts against 28% of posts without a link.

For each account with at least three link posts and three link-free posts of the same type, we divided the median views of its link posts by the median views of its link-free posts. The tables report the median of those ratios across accounts, with a 95% bootstrap interval for the headline. 68,604 accounts had at least three posts with a link and three without; 18,341 of them qualified for the text comparison and 41,078 for the image or video comparison. Follower bands use the median follower count recorded when each account's posts were read.

As a check, we repeated the comparison on posts whose views were read at least seven days after publication (posts to October 2). The text-only gap was -10.2% across 12,327 accounts, and -30.4% for accounts over 1 million followers, close to the main result. Requiring five posts in each group instead of three gave -14.1% for text posts.

Limitations

• This is an observational comparison. Comparing an account with itself removes differences between accounts, but not differences between the posts an account chooses to link: a news account may link its routine articles and post its biggest story as a video. Part of the gap may be that choice, not X's ranking.
• We read outcomes, not X's code. The numbers say link posts reach fewer people; they cannot say whether X applies a rule to links or whether the gap comes from how people react to them.
• The sample leans toward large accounts, because our crawler reads the biggest accounts first. The under 1,000 band rests on 1,392 accounts for text posts and should be read with that in mind.
• X's view counter counts impressions as X defines them. We use it as published and cannot audit it.
• A link to another X post or profile counts as a link if X reports it as a URL. Quote posts are excluded.
• Link-in-reply detection depends on our crawler having read the reply. A post whose linked reply we missed sits in the no-link group, which would shrink the differences in that table, not create them.
• We have no post data from before July 2026, so we cannot say whether the gap was larger a year ago.

Frequently asked questions

Does X penalize links in 2026?

X says it does not, and Elon Musk said in July 2026 that it had not for over a year. In PlayerSells' measurement of 6,447,046 posts from July 15 to October 7, 2026, text posts with a link still drew 10% fewer views than the same account's text posts without a link, and 30% fewer for accounts with over 1 million followers.

How many fewer views does a post with a link get on X?

For the median account, 10% fewer on text posts and 7% fewer on posts with an image or video, compared with the same account's posts without a link. Accounts under 1,000 followers saw no loss, and accounts over 1 million followers lost 30% on text posts.

Should I put the link in a reply on X?

In our data it still helped. Posts with the link in the author's own reply drew 21% more views than the same account's posts with the link in the post (text posts) and 16% more with an image or video. Part of that comes from replying under your own post at all.

Is the 94% figure for link posts on X correct?

It does not match what we measured. Across 18,341 accounts the median gap for text posts was 10%, and even accounts with over 1 million followers lost 30%. PPC Land reported the 94% figure from its own analysis; X has not published a figure of its own.

Do link posts get less engagement on X?

Yes. Text posts with a link collected 48% fewer likes per view than the same account's posts without a link, a larger gap than the gap in views.

Can I use this data?

Yes. The aggregate tables are published as an open dataset under CC BY 4.0 at github.com/playersells/open-data. Please credit PlayerSells with a link to this page.

More measurements from PlayerSells

• Does X Premium increase reach? 60,000 accounts compared
• Best time to post on X: what the data shows
• X bookmark rate benchmarks across 94,318 accounts
• What the open source X algorithm actually contains
• What is a good engagement rate on X?
• How much of Kick is gambling, measured against Twitch
• Crypto Telegram channels are losing subscribers
• Kick and Twitch simulcasting: where viewers watch
• X engagement rate benchmarks, updated daily
• Free X engagement rate calculator